Come On Down to Whataboutisms Plus!!! Your One-Stop Shop for All Things “Whataboutism”

October 1, 2023 By Dennis Knapp

Hi there, friends! Dennis Knapp, here, from Whataboutisms Plus!!! Your one-stop shop for all things “whataboutism.” Looking for excuses for horrible opinions and need “reasons” to hold them? Then come on down! Want to support abortion rights but still think it’s a little icky? Check out our selection of: “What about” poor minority women of color? Or “What about” complicated pregnancies? Sure, these “whataboutisms” do make up the smallest percentages of abortions, but here at Whataboutisms Plus!!! the name... Read more

Appeal to Conscience or Exemption from Sin? The Slow Death of Catholic Conscience

September 28, 2023 By Dennis Knapp

0 Comments

The false appeal to “follow your conscience” so as to exempt oneself from following the Church’s moral teaching has had incalculable consequences. Many Catholics consider their own desires, not the Church’s teaching, to be the standard for good behavior. The Church becomes a point of reference for selective consultation on matters of morality. She is no longer considered the teacher of universal truths binding upon the consciences of believers. “Cafeteria Catholicism,” pick and choose whatever you like, is a widespread... Read more

Marginalized By Rome: No Room in “Enlarged Tent” For Traditionalist Catholics

September 18, 2023 By Dennis Knapp

0 Comments

We live in the midst of a “synodal renewal of the Church.” This Church “listens” and “accompanies” God’s people, especially those on the “margins” (the marginalized). Starting in October of 2023, representatives of the Catholic Church begin meeting in Rome for the First Session of the Synod of Synodality. Here, the Church takes the information gleaned from the various “listen sessions” and begins to identify new ways to “accompany” its people, again, especially those on the “margins.” Well, not all... Read more

How to Demoralize the Church

September 13, 2023 By Dennis Knapp

0 Comments

The current messaging coming from the Vatican baffles me. The Vatican appears to stand by while some bishops (especially in Germany) seek to change Catholic moral teaching. Pope Francis elevates cardinals among American prelates that dissent from Catholic moral teaching. Moreover, the Pope overlooks more faithful bishops and archbishops of dioceses that traditionally hold cardinals. The Pope labels “conservative” American Catholics ideologues. Young, more traditional priests, he labels too “ridged” or someone where “something bad is happening…on the inside.” And... Read more

Conservative Priests Are Finally Here. Laudem Dei!

September 8, 2023 By Dennis Knapp

0 Comments

The Church in the United States stands in the mists of sea change concerning the priesthood. From at least 2002, studies conducted on the priesthood show that most new priests ordained in the Catholic Church reflect a more traditional and conservative worldview. I often highlight concerns over potential heterodoxic and heteropraxic (unorthodox belief and practice) movements within the Church. These movements often surround progressive Catholic prelates. For example, the German Synodal Way, which authorized the blessing of same-sex couples, in... Read more

3 Things Some Progressive Catholics Want (In My Opinion)

September 3, 2023 By Dennis Knapp

0 Comments

As a “conservative” Catholic, I often get pushback from “progressive” Catholics. They claim I am too Pharisaical, too judgmental, too imprudent, or just plain rude. Our ethical standards appear miles apart, yet we share the same Catholic Church. Why do they think I am rude? Well, I think Catholic moral teaching applies to all Catholics, regardless of situation or circumstance.* The word catholic means universal, therefore Catholic moral teaching applies universally to all Catholics. In this article, I put forth,... Read more

Guest Contributor Todd Flowerday: Fear is Useless; What is Needed is Trust

September 2, 2023 By Dennis Knapp

0 Comments

In the spirit of dialogue, I provided one of my critics a space to contribute. His essay is below. Thank you for reading. Fear is useless; what is needed is trust From the last thread, it’s no secret I was alarmed at Cardinal Burke’s seeming ignorance on the history of Church meetings–councils, synods, and other forms of consultation. In its broad sense, synodality happens all the time in the Church: parish councils, finance committees, and even the one-on-one experiences common in everyday life.... Read more

Cracking the Code of Synodality

August 31, 2023 By Dennis Knapp

0 Comments

In a recent article, A Synod of Disappointment Looms: Who Is This Synod for Anyway?, I asked the question: who is the Synod of Synodality (SoS) for anyway? I examined the document release as guidance for the First Session, Instrumentum Laboris (IL), for insight into the ultimate ends of the SoS. Not alone in my confusion, one need only scan websites like The National Catholic Register and The Catholic Thing to find numerous articles attempting to crack the code of... Read more

Sharing Truth in Love Means…

August 26, 2023 By Dennis Knapp

0 Comments

How do we share the revealed truth found in Christianity, especially when this truth causes discomfort or demands a change in behavior? In Ephesians, St. Paul ties revealed truth with the attainment of maturity and seeing beyond deceitful schemes. This newly attained truth is the context in which love speaks. And he gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds and teachers, to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of Christ, until... Read more